The Milos Atlantis Conference (Greece)“The Atlantis Hypothesis: Searching for a Lost Land”took place between 11th and 13th July 2005. Specialists in the fields of archaeology, geology, volcanology and other sciences presented and substantiated their viewsregarding the place where Atlantis existed, the time when it was destroyed and the causes of its destruction,whilst a number of people expressed their doubts as to whether it actually existed.Based on the accounts of Plato, the conference participants agreed on the following 24 criteria,which a geographical area must satisfy in order to qualify as a site where Atlantis could have existed:
1.The
Metropolis of Atlantis should have been located where an island used to be and
where parts of it may still exist.
2. The Metropolis of Atlantis should have had a most distinct geomorphology
composed of alternating concentric rings of land and water.
3. The Atlantis should have been located outside the Pillars of Hercules.
4. The Metropolis of Atlantis was greater than Libya and Anatolia and Middle
East and Sinai (combined).
5. Atlantis must have sheltered a literate population with metallurgical and
navigational skills.
6. The Metropolis of Atlantis should have been routinely reachable from Athens
by sea.
7. At the time, Atlantis should have been at war with Athens.
8. The Metropolis of Athens must have suffered a devastating physical
destruction of unprecedented proportions.
9. The Metropolis of Atlantis should have sunk entirely or partly below the
water.
10. The Metropolis of Atlantis was destroyed 9000 Egyptian years before the 6th
century B.C.
11. The part of Atlantis was 50 stadia (7,5 km) from the city.
12. Atlantis had a high population density, enough to support a large army
(10,000 chariots, 1,200 ships, 1,200,000 hoplites)
13. The region of Atlantis involved the sacrifice of bulls.
14. The destruction of Atlantis was accompanied by an earthquake.
15. After the destruction of Atlantis, the passage of ships was blocked.
16. Elephants were present in Atlantis.
17.
No physically or geologically impossible processes were involved in the
destruction of Atlantis.
18. Hot and cold springs, with mineral deposits, were present in Atlantis.
19. Atlantis lay on a coastal plain 2000 X 3000 stadia surrounded by mountains
falling into the sea.
20. Atlantis controlled other states of the period.
21. Winds in Atlantis came from the north (only in Northern hemisphere)
22. The rocks in Atlantis were of various colors: black, white, and red.
23. There were canals for irrigation in Atlantis.
24. Every 5th and 6th year, they sacrificed bulls.
Using the above criteria, independently arrived at by the
conference participants, the editor of this page has compiled the following
table which illustrates how the various locations proposed for Atlantis may fit
or not fit, as the case may be, the criteria for Atlantis.
|
Atlantis
conference Milos List
of points for Atlantis location
and features |
Bolivan Altiplano |
Cyprus |
Thera |
Malta |
Straits of Gibraltar |
Azores |
Off Cuba |
Malasia |
Antarctica |
|
|
1.The
Metropolis of Atlantis should have been located where an island used to be
and where parts of it may still exist. |
Yes at Pampa
Aullagas, easily
verified |
Difficult
to verify, Under
water |
Yes |
Malta Is an island |
Difficult
to verify, Under water |
yes |
Difficult
to verify, Under water |
Various islands |
An
island continent |
|
|
2.
The Metropolis of Atlantis should have had a most distinct geomorphology
composed of alternating concentric rings of land and water. |
Yes at Pampa
Aullagas, easily verified |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
|
|
3.
The Atlantis should have been located outside the Pillars of Hercules. |
Yes at Pampa
Aullagas, easily
verified |
no |
no |
no |
yes |
yes |
yes |
yes but
Plato said it was in the Atlantic Ocean |
yes |
|
|
4.
The Metropolis of Atlantis was greater than Libya and Anatolia and Middle
East and Sinai (combined). |
Yes The
continent of Atlantis is now called “South America |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
yes |
|
|
5.
Atlantis must have sheltered a literate population with metallurgical and
navigational skills. |
Yes Difficult to prove since it was destroyed but later people had both metallurigical
and navigational skills |
|
Yes |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
6.
The Metropolis of Atlantis should have been routinely reachable from Athens
by sea. |
Yes Coca
and tobacco were found in Egyptian mummies, “Bolivian”
pyramids are built in “Egyptian”
cubits and cuneiform writing has been found near Lake Titicaca |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
not
probable |
not probable |
|
|
7.
At the time, Atlantis should have been at war with Athens. |
Difficult to prove, but probably refers to the invasion of Egypt
and Greece by the “Sea Peoples” |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
8.
The Metropolis of Athens must have suffered a devastating physical
destruction of unprecedented proportions. |
Yes at Pampa
Aullagas, easily
verified |
no |
Yes |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
|
|
9.
The Metropolis of Atlantis should have sunk entirely or partly below the
water. |
Yes at Pampa
Aullagas, easily
verified |
claimed
but difficult to verify |
Yes |
no |
claimed
but difficult to verify |
no |
claimed
but difficult to verify |
no |
no |
|
|
10.
The Metropolis of Atlantis was destroyed 9000 Egyptian years before the 6th
century B.C. |
Difficult to verify an actual date |
Difficult to verify an actual date |
Some
say dividing years by 10 would fit Thera |
Difficult to verify an actual date |
Difficult to verify an actual date |
Difficult to verify an actual date |
Difficult to verify an actual date |
Difficult to verify an actual date |
Difficult to verify an actual date |
|
|
11.
The part of Atlantis was 50 stadia (7,5 km) from the city. This should
read “the sea was 50 stadia from the city” |
Yes at Pampa
Aullagas, easily
verified |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
|
|
12.
Atlantis had a high population density, enough to support a large army
(10,000 chariots, 1,200 ships, 1,200,000 hoplites) |
Yes Difficult
to verify, but before the conquest, South America had a vast population |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
|
|
13.
The region of Atlantis involved the sacrifice of bulls. |
Yes For
“bulls” read “llamas” which are still sacrificed there today. |
not
known |
Yes Bull
games on crete |
no |
not
known |
no |
not
probable |
not
probable |
no |
|
|
|
Bolivan Altiplano |
Cyprus |
Thera |
Malta |
Straits of Gibraltar |
Azores |
Off Cuba |
Malasia |
Antarctica |
|
|
14.
The destruction of Atlantis was accompanied by an earthquake. |
Yes at Pampa
Aullagas, easily
verified |
no |
Thera
was destroyed by volcanic eruption, not earthquakes |
no |
not
known |
no |
Yes earthquake zone |
no |
no |
|
|
15.
After the destruction of Atlantis, the passage of ships was blocked. |
Yes Nearby
Lake Poopo is today not passable |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
|
|
16. Elephants were present in Atlantis. |
Yes at Pampa
Aullagas, easily
verified |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
Yes |
no |
|
|
17.
No physically or geologically impossible processes were involved in the
destruction of Atlantis |
Yes The Altiplano is subject to the earthquakes and floods Plato
mentioned |
|
Yes |
No. no
sunken island |
|
No. entire
continents cannot sink in a single day |
Yes earthquake zone |
No. entire
continents cannot sink in a single day |
No. has
been under ice for a longer period than Plato’s timescale |
|
|
18.
Hot and cold springs, with mineral deposits, were present in Atlantis. Editor’s
note, the minerals were gold, silver, copper, tin and orichalcum |
Yes at Pampa
Aullagas, easily
verified and the only site with all the minerals Plato mentioned |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
Yes |
no |
|
|
19.
Atlantis lay on a coastal plain 2000 X 3000 stadia surrounded by mountains
falling into the sea. |
Yes at Pampa
Aullagas, easily
verified |
no |
No Even
if the plain were on Crete and divided by 10, it would be too large to fit. |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
|
|
|
Bolivan Altiplano |
Cyprus |
Thera |
Malta |
Straits of Gibraltar |
Azores |
Off Cuba |
Malasia |
Antarctica |
|
|
20.
Atlantis controlled other states of the period. |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult
to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
|
|
21.
Winds in Atlantis came from the north (only in Northern hemisphere) |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult
to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
|
|
22.
The rocks in Atlantis were of various colors: black, white, and red. |
Yes at Pampa
Aullagas, easily
verified |
no |
Yes Not known, but is Indicative of a volcanic environment |
no |
Not
known |
Yes Indicative of a volcanic environment |
no |
no |
no |
|
|
23.
There were canals for irrigation in Atlantis. |
Yes Visible
on satellite images of the Altiplano |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
no |
|
|
24.
Every 5th and 6th year, they sacrificed bulls. |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult
to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
Difficult to prove |
|
|
|
total19 |
total 1 |
total 8 |
total 1 |
total 2 |
total 4 |
total 4 |
total 3 |
total 2 |
|
|
|
Bolivan Altiplano |
Cyprus |
Thera |
Malta |
Straits of Gibraltar |
Azores |
Off Cuba |
Malasia |
Antarctica |
|
From the above criteria as
defined by the Milos conference, the key points must surely be the geographic description of the island i.e. in particular (2) that it should have a particular geomorphology
composed of alternating concentric rings of land and water, (3) should have been located outside the Pillars
of Hercules, (4) The Metropolis of Atlantis was greater than Libya and Anatolia and Middle East and Sinai combined (18) Hot and cold springs, with mineral deposits, were
present in Atlantis,
(19) Atlantis lay on a coastal plain 2000 X 3000 stadia surrounded by mountains falling into
the sea, (22) The rocks in Atlantis were of various colors: black, white, and red,
(23) There were canals for irrigation in Atlantis.
The only candidate site which
contains an island with the specific geomorphology of the alternating rings of
land and water, destroyed by earthquakes and floods and which also lies on a rectangular
level plain which in turn is in the centre of a continent opposite the Pillars
of Hercules is Pampa Aullagas on the Bolvian Altiplano and the lack of these key,
determining features surely disqualifies the other candidates.
The
viewer may also like to visit http://www.realatlantis.com/statementscomparison50points.htm
for a list of 50 points of comparison between the Bolivian Altiplano and
Plato’s Atlantis